In this insightful second part of our series, we cast a spotlight on the January transfer window strategies of Manchester United and Chelsea. From United’s active player movements to Chelsea’s challenge of managing a bloated squad, we dissect the tactics and decisions that are shaping these Premier League giants in the midst of a pivotal transfer period.

Manchester United

Manchester United’s approach to the transfer market starkly contrasts that of their city rivals. The Red Devils are perennially active in transfer dealings, often involving both incoming and outgoing players, regardless of immediate needs or strategic objectives. 

This winter window is no exception, with most of the buzz revolving around players exiting Old Trafford.

One of the headline stories is Jadon Sancho’s loan move back to Borussia Dortmund. 

This development follows a protracted disagreement with coach Erik ten Hag, leading to a temporary return to his former club in a bid to rediscover his form.

Another notable loan involves Donny van de Beek, who has joined Eintracht Frankfurt. Van de Beek’s move is a clear attempt to reboot his career, having found opportunities limited under Ten Hag’s management.

The trend of loans and potential exits extends to other young talents at United. Amad Diallo and Hannibal, both promising prospects, are reportedly on the radar of several European clubs, indicating potential moves. 

Anthony Martial’s situation is also drawing attention. Despite his apparent desire to leave Manchester United, as reported by BBC Sport, he has turned down offers from Saudi Arabian clubs. Inter Milan, however, remains a viable destination for the French forward.

The central midfield remains a conspicuous challenge for Manchester United. Despite the additions of Casemiro and Sofyan Amrabat, the team struggles to find the stability and technical assurance needed in this crucial area. 

This issue is not only about unlocking the potential of players like Scott McTominay, but also preparing for the return of the injured Mason Mount. United’s midfield, as it stands, lacks the cohesive element vital for the team’s overall balance and fluidity.

The current market conditions – marked by high demand for quality midfielders and limited availability – make it difficult for United to address this issue effectively in the January window. 

It might be more prudent for the club to bide their time, waiting for the ideal opportunity to make a significant midfield signing in the summer.

The departure of Jadon on loan brings another pressing issue for United to the forefront: the right-wing position. Antony, despite being a high-profile signing, has yet to live up to the expectations. Coach Erik ten Hag has been vocal about Antony’s performance not meeting the required standards, attributing some of these shortcomings to off-field issues.

With no links to other right-wingers in the current transfer market, it appears that Antony will continue to be a regular starter. Manchester United, therefore, faces the task of getting the best out of Antony in the coming months while possibly eyeing a strategic addition to their wing options in the summer. 

Manchester United’s transfer rumblings have recently linked the club with Stuttgart striker Serhou Guirassy, who has made a mark as one of the Bundesliga’s top scorers.  

At 27 years old, Guirassy’s prowess in front of goal is notable, but his potential move to United raises questions. Currently representing Guinea in the AFCON, his acquisition would come at a time when United’s Andreas Højlund is struggling, a situation exacerbated by the team’s issues on the right wing and in midfield.

The necessity of adding another striker, given these existing challenges, is a point of contention.

Beyond the forward line, Manchester United’s defence also warrants attention. Raphael Varane’s fluctuating form has been a concern, leaving Lisandro Martinez as the only consistently reliable defender.

This situation highlights a clear need for defensive reinforcements. The quiet transfer activity from United in this area is surprising, especially considering the necessity for change. The recent incorporation of Jonny Evans from Leicester City is a step in addressing this, but more needs to be done to bolster the back line.

Chelsea

Chelsea’s situation stands in stark contrast to many of their Premier League rivals. Rather than needing additional signings, the club is confronted with the challenge of managing an oversized squad, a consequence of the transfer frenzy following Todd Boehly’s takeover from Roman Abramovich. 

Reports from The Athletic have even highlighted logistical issues, such as a lack of space in the dressing room, underscoring the extent of the club’s over-recruitment. 

Among the plethora of players at Chelsea, a few, including the veteran Thiago Silva, are expected to seek an exit soon. However, a more immediate focus for the club is the return of key players from injury.

Lavia, who was one of the standout signings last summer alongside Colwill, Palmer, and Nkunku, is particularly anticipated to make a significant impact upon his return. Nkunku’s recovery is also eagerly awaited, given his prolonged absence due to injury.

The current predicament for Chelsea is not just about trimming down the squad size but also about finding a coherent direction under Mauricio Pochettino’s management.

This process of streamlining the squad is likely to be more pronounced in the summer rather than the winter window. For now, the priority is to navigate the remainder of the season with the existing personnel while still trying to climb up from their mid-table position.


More analytics on soccer:

More Predictions: